First, many apologies for my absence from the
blog. October has been a bit of an up and
down month to say the least. I was very
busy at the end of September at work, and as soon as I finished the project I
was working on I caught ‘flu.
I’ve only had it once before, and I hadn’t
remembered how awful it can be. It’s
taken a good two weeks to get over the worst of it, and in the process I’ve had
to miss a great weekend of gaming in Burton with a couple of very good friends,
Simon Gaudin and Craig Ambler. Best laid
plans and so forth – but all the same, I was deeply sorry I had to miss the
weekend.
Laid up in bed, there’ve been few high
spots of the last couple of weeks in wargaming terms. There’s not much you can do with the ‘flu
other than lie in bed, as I am sure many of you know through similarly wretched
experiences. However, over the last week
things have been getting back to normal and I’ve been working (very slowly) on
my pictish warband. More of that in the
weeks to come.
I also finally managed to concentrate on a
couple of books I’ve been saving for a while.
One of them is Thomas Wictor’s “German Assault Troops of World War
I”. This is a very lavish reference
work, written by a very prominent contributor to various Great War online
forums and follows his very well received first book on “German Flamethrower
Pioneers of World War I”. I thought I'd take the oportunity to review it here.
As you may already have guessed, we are in
somewhat specialized territory here, focusing on a numerically small but
well-known part of the Kaiser’s Army.
There have been a number of reputable and respected books on the
evolution of the German stosstruppen in the Great War, focusing on the history
and use of these formations. But few
works have drawn together the volume of original photographs, extracts from
contemporary military manuals and small-unit level tactical insights as Mr
Wictor’s book has done. I therefore think
that there’s a worthy place on the shelf for “German Assault Troops of World
War I”, filling a niche that isn’t really covered by the other standard works
by Professor Gudmundsson, Dr Samuels and Dr Bull.
The obvious drawback with the book is the
price. As a very limited edition, the
price of £55 is certainly steep, although you do get a very handsome hardbacked
volume with 320 pages of genuinely new (at least to me) information and
photographs. I was lucky enough to have
an Amazon voucher for my birthday, which helped with the cost, but I would
recommend the book for anyone interested in the subject or interested in more
than the commonly available background works on the stosstruppen of the Great
War.
All in all, an excellent book, if a little expensive. For those interested in the subject, a clear 5 out of 5 star-shells, with a strong recommendation for those building stosstrupp forces in 28mm.
There are some absences in the book, but these can mainly be supplemented with the other standard works on stormtroopers. One possible omission remains the interaction between the reality of wartime stormtroop operations and the immediate post-war Weimar period. I’ve been curious for some time as to the extent that a clear lineage can be traced from the stosstrupps of the Imperial German Army to the Freikorps which formed in early Weimer Germany. I’ve also thought that a study of the representation (and misrepresentation) of stormtroopers in literature, art, and propaganda in Weimar Germany would be a great subject for a book. Sadly, we’ll need to wait a little longer for such a volume. In the meantime, “German Assault Troops of World War I” should keep me busy.
Thanks for the heads up, have not come across this one before. Glad to see you are on the mend, I had a very bad bout a few years ago, I was off work for 2 weeks and it was another 2 after that before I felt 100% Always made me smile afterwards when guys would be off a couple days and said they had flu. Look frward to seeing your Picts in due course.
ReplyDeleteThanks Phil. Yes, I'd also forgotten how it knocks you for six! All the same, getting back to normal now, thanks. And yes, the picts are slowly getting done.....at last!
Delete£55 is probably a little to expensive for me with a specialist subject, but luckily we will be able to get all the benefits from it in your future blogs. Glad to hear you are feeling better.
ReplyDeleteThanks Pat. Yes, it's definately a "minority interest" title. I kept being intrigued by it, but couldn't find anything online about the content and presentation of the book. I wanted to try and help out with that and let people know that, if they were interested, it was worthwhile - albeit at a high price. And yes, the additional piint was very much to give you all the benefit of the content through some new scenarios and battle-reports. So hopefully you win either way, purchaser or not!
DeleteThat's a bit too expensive for me too, but hey if its your thing, then you've just gotta go for it!!
ReplyDeleteThanks Ray! Yes, it was pricey, but hopefully you'll get the benefit of some of Mr Wictor's research from what I'll be posting here over the winter. All the best!
DeleteAnother good book that you may want to look at is Christian Ortner's "Storm Troops: Austro-Hungarian Assault Units and Commandos in the First World War: Tactics, Organization and Equipment." It is a really good book on the Austro-Hungarians.
ReplyDeleteOoooh, thanks Chris! That's a great heads-up! I shall definately look out for that one. I'd not come across it before. Thanks very much!
DeleteSounds the business, great new header by the way!
ReplyDeleteThanks Fran, very glad you like it!
DeleteIf it gives you what you wanted, then the price is too little compared to the final outcome. Have fun reading it over and over again Sidney. And as Fran said, nice header! :)
ReplyDeleteThanks mate! It was one of those books that I looked at again and again on-line, wondering and thinking. In the end, I got the chance to buy a copy and I'm really pleased I have done. It's strange you know, because over the years I've collected a lot of books at around the £10 to £20 mark which are, well, you know.....so-so. They've been OK to read, but nothing special. With this book, it was a lot more than I would usually pay, but I held off getting a couple of other books and concentrated on getting this one. In the end, I was glad I did. I'm sure there' some sort of 'life-message' in there somewhere!!! Whatever that message, it's been fun to read and, in the end, that's what's really important. Thanks again for commenting!
DeleteGood to see you back - you were missed. And yes, flu.. really... really... sucks. I got the Xmas 2009 bout which basically wiped me for a fortnight, and some weird imported American strain last autumn which was the first time I think I've ever had a doctor's note keeping me off work.
ReplyDeleteThanks Mike, it is genuinely great to be back. Thanks for all yours and Andy's good thoughts from Peterborough! I share you 'flu-experiences! It really was a dreadful curve-ball, but feeling much, much better now thanks, mate!
DeleteSidney, soooo good to see you back in the front.
ReplyDeleteThe initial message from Rich in the Yahoo Group was really scary.
Get well and don't overreach yourself
Benito, thanks so much for the post, and your very kind thoughts! I'm feeling much better now, and looking forward to easing myself back into the hobby! Thanks again for your really kind messages on the group and here, mate!
Delete